La Plume à Papotte


 
AccueilAccueil  PortailPortail  FAQFAQ  RechercherRechercher  S'enregistrerS'enregistrer  MembresMembres  GroupesGroupes  ConnexionConnexion  

Partagez | 
 

 The third film, tricky to be sure of what really happened?

Aller en bas 
AuteurMessage
dublin
Papotteur bavard


Nombre de messages : 106
Date d'inscription : 03/11/2004

MessageSujet: The third film, tricky to be sure of what really happened?   Lun 28 Mar à 16:14

I was wondering something yesterday, and maybe one of you can answer my question.
When the Buckbick (no idea how to write the name) is going to be killed, Hermione, Ron and Harry are in Hagrid's hut. Then Hermione "past" launches a stone at Harry's head so that they realise they have to leave the hut. They go out of the hut from the back while the "past" who were behind the pumpkins get on to the top of the "hill". Then the "past" hide in the forest, while H, R, and Harry hide behind the pumpkins and then whe fude and the others entered the hut, they go on to the top of the "hill".

My question : As the camera does not show Buckbick when it is supposed to get its head chopped, do you think that it is still alive at the end the first stage or that it has actually really been killed and the "past" is then going to come to save the bird?

The big question: did Dumbledore knew from the biginning what was going to happen, did he decide from the beginning that they were going to return in the past and save the bird?
I know it is not really clear so if you have questions
, ask me.
Revenir en haut Aller en bas
Voir le profil de l'utilisateur
Mélanie de Bricassart
Gourou des papotteurs
avatar

Nombre de messages : 4342
Localisation : A Godric's Hollow dans l'ancienne maison des Potter, je la protège de la curiosité des moldus.
Date d'inscription : 28/10/2004

MessageSujet: Re: The third film, tricky to be sure of what really happened?   Dim 3 Avr à 19:17

So I think that the time is a big circle... So I think that Buckbik has never been killed, even when Harry and cie thought he had been killed.
Revenir en haut Aller en bas
Voir le profil de l'utilisateur http://www.thethornbirds.forumactif.com
Jana
L'Administratrice Mégalo
L'Administratrice Mégalo
avatar

Nombre de messages : 1185
Localisation : Entre le Ministère de la magie de Finlande, de France et d'Angleterre
<br><font color=\"blue\">Loisirs</f : tricoter
Date d'inscription : 27/10/2004

MessageSujet: Re: The third film, tricky to be sure of what really happened?   Dim 3 Avr à 21:24

well actually buckbeak wasn t beheaded in both of the section...because Harry was there to save him...in the first section when we are not supposed to know that Harry and Hermione were going back in Time Harry is hit by the stone and Hermione looked in the Wood because she has seen something...so The Harry and hermione were there to save Buckbeak all the time...hope you understand

_________________

Je modère en rouge foncé
Revenir en haut Aller en bas
Voir le profil de l'utilisateur
Invité
Invité



MessageSujet: Re: The third film, tricky to be sure of what really happened?   Lun 4 Avr à 16:23

Yep so it is clear that the camera wants us to THINK it is killed but actually he is not.
Ok, understood. It's bloody well done!
Revenir en haut Aller en bas
Contenu sponsorisé




MessageSujet: Re: The third film, tricky to be sure of what really happened?   

Revenir en haut Aller en bas
 
The third film, tricky to be sure of what really happened?
Revenir en haut 
Page 1 sur 1
 Sujets similaires
-
» George Sand et Musset (film, romans, théâtre et lettres)
» Les acteurs du film
» Gears of War - Le Film
» Marathon Anne of Green Gables semaine 2 - 2ème téléfilm
» FESTIVAL FILM FANTASTIQUE + EXPO ALIEN à STRASBOURG

Permission de ce forum:Vous ne pouvez pas répondre aux sujets dans ce forum
La Plume à Papotte :: Espace détente :: English forum Anglais-
Sauter vers: